43 Years of Serving Sarasota
Welcome to Kagy's Jewelry Box, where we are proud to offer a unique blend of unparalleled customer service, expert craftsmanship, and timeless treasures to Sarasota, Florida. Our family-owned and operated business is rooted in strong Christian values, and we are dedicated to fostering relationships, honor, and integrity in everything we do.
Our story began with the passion of our founders, Butch and Janie Kagy, who established a reputation for exceptional quality and personalized service. Today, the legacy continues with their son, Steve Kagy, and his wife Sam, who, along with their children Nate, Abby, Josephine, and Josh, strive to maintain the same commitment to excellence that has distinguished Kagy's Jewelry Box for generations.
At Kagy's Jewelry Box, we pride ourselves on being your trusted neighborhood jeweler, offering a wide selection of exquisite jewelry and timepieces. While we may not be a big box store, we are confident that if we don't carry it, we can get it for you. Our friendly and knowledgeable staff is always eager to help you find the perfect piece to celebrate life's most precious moments.
In addition to our selection of stunning jewelry, we also specialize in custom work, providing you with the opportunity to bring your unique vision to life. Our skilled artisans work closely with you to create personalized pieces that capture your style and tell your story.
Our services extend beyond sales to include jewelry servicing and repair, watch battery replacement, and watch repair. We understand the sentimental value behind each piece and treat your treasured items with the utmost care and attention they deserve.
As a family-owned business, we cherish the importance of spending time with loved ones. In honor of our strong Christian values, we are closed on Sundays, allowing our team to rest and enjoy quality time with their families.
Thank you for choosing Kagy's Jewelry Box. We look forward to serving you and your family for generations to come.
What People Are Saying
-
MIDGE M.
“I have been taking my jewelry for repairs here for many years. They are experts and very fairly priced. They also have some beautiful estate pieces.”
-
DELORES D.
“Went in today with a client of mine who has Alzheimer's Dementia... her watch band sprung and wasn't holding to her wrist anymore so we needed to get her a new band. Wasn't sure what to expect when we went there I had read reviews by other people and said let's give it a shot. When we went in we were greeted by 2 smiling faces. 2 ladies asked how they could help and after a while of interacting with my client they caught on that she had a memory loss. They were very patient and kind. And very understanding. Would definitely come back here again. I recommend 10/10. Also they serviced her watch so fast! She found a band she loved and I want to say 10mins max and the cost of the band... they had is fit for her and ready. Thank you for being to kind!”
-
ESTY D.
”The pros at Katy's resized my late grandmother's vintage white gold ring with intricate filigree design by 3 ring sizes. The result is shockingly excellent. I was not optimistic, but they did a seamless job - amazing! I am so thankful!” -
CAL S.
“These guys are awesome! I had an engagement ring I wanted customized before I popped the big question. I wanted to change a couple accent stones to personalize the ring. I had gotten a couple quotes elsewhere and ended up taking it to Kagy due to my initial experiences.They were very friendly, gave me a quote and ordered in a few different stones to let me decide on the best way forward. They finished the work and ended up charging me a little less than they quoted because it was "without complication." It came out perfect.
Couldn't be happier with the whole process and customer service. And to top it off, she said Yes!”
-
MONICA M.
“This is the best jeweler in town! I take my jewelry in here for cleanings, new batteries and fixing. Today I just needed to have the back put on my watch because it dropped..She fixed it immediately and didn't charge me. I always come here and will continue. Thank you” -
RITCHIE G.
”Great guys. Fast and fairly priced. AND they are open Saturdays. Highly recommended for watch repair work.” -
DEB L.
”A friend referred me to Kagy's for repairs on a couple of pieces of jewelry. Super fast service, very friendly, easy location to find. They did great work for me. I will return.” -
PAUL R.
”Great job with watch... fast, honest, and efficient.. Highly recommend Very pleases with two one-on one interaction between the owners and myself. They communicated in a timely way and honestly completed the work.” -
HEATHER G.
”I'm so happy I found this store! They are so nice and very knowledgeable and will always take my jewelry to them! They have earned a customer for life!” -
SELMY B.
“Reasonable prices, Excellent Service, and the work is done by experts. This is a family owned business and retains the personal touch. Not a huge selection of jewelry in stock; however, if you want something they will try to get it for you. Repairs are done correctly and if there's something you don't like, they will fix it. Local home town jewelers.” -
ANN M.
”My fiancé and I needed to purchase our wedding rings and we definitely came to the right place! Excellent, quality customer service! Couldn't have been more pleased with this experience. Before leaving, one of the clerks noted: "We don't sell jewelry, we create memories." I couldn't agree more, what a special memory we will always cherish. Thank you!”
